Every Scoop Tells
a Story
Worth Savoring
Small-batch ice cream crafted by hand, right here on North First Street. We source local dairy, stir every batch with patience, and never rush a flavor to market.
Family owned and
operated since day one
Rotating Flavors,
Constant Quality
We change our menu with the seasons and let inspiration strike. Here's what's spinning in our batch freezer right now.
Emerald Mint Chip
Fresh mint infused into our cream base, folded with dark chocolate shards. Our most requested flavor for a reason.
Vanilla Cloud
Madagascar vanilla beans steeped overnight, churned to a cloud-like texture. Simple, but never boring.
Strawberry Blossom
Local strawberries pureed and swirled into a sweet cream base. Picked fresh, scooped fresh.
Treasure Chest Chocolate
Double cocoa base with fudge ripple and cocoa nib crunch. For those who like it bold.
Salted Caramel Tide
Buttery caramel ribbons through a vanilla base, finished with a whisper of sea salt. Addictively smooth.
Blueberry Dusk
Wild blueberries folded into a lavender-hinted cream. A twilight flavor that tastes like a summer evening.
Flavors rotate weekly. Call ahead to check what's fresh today.
Born in Pierceton,
Crafted with Care
Lost Treasures Ice Cream started as a simple idea: make ice cream the way your grandmother used to — slowly, with real ingredients, and without shortcuts.
We set up shop on North First Street because this town deserved a place where ice cream wasn't just a treat, but an experience. Every batch is made by hand in small quantities, using local dairy and seasonal fruit whenever it's available.
No mixers on autopilot. No industrial shortcuts. Just patience, quality ingredients, and a lot of love going into every container that leaves our kitchen.
More Than a Scoop —
It's a Memory in the Making
Whether you're pulling over after a walk through downtown Pierceton, treating the kids after school, or just craving something that tastes like it was made for you — we've got a spot waiting.
Come Say Hello
We're right in the heart of Pierceton. Walk in, look at the display, and let us help you find your next favorite flavor.
Address
117 N 1st St
Pierceton, IN 46562-9336
Phone
Hours
Mon – Sat: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
